Fair Work Centre — For Employers
Terminating an employee is lawful when you have a valid reason, a fair process, the notice the National Employment Standards require and correct final pay. Get any one of those wrong and the decision becomes an unfair dismissal claim. This guide sets out the whole process, and how Fair Work Centre gets employers through it.
Employer Guide
Termination of employment is lawful when four things are true: you have a valid reason, the process is fair, you give the notice or payment in lieu required under section 117 of the Fair Work Act 2009, and you pay out every entitlement on the final pay. Employment ends lawfully in only a few ways — resignation, genuine redundancy, dismissal with notice, or summary dismissal for serious misconduct.
Most claims we defend were avoidable. The employer had a defensible reason but lost the case on process: no written allegations, no chance to respond, or a decision made before anyone looked at the evidence. The Fair Work Commission reviews both limbs under section 387, and a strong reason does not rescue a flawed process. The Commission publishes its own guidance on terminating employment, and the figures below are the ones that decide whether a claim can be brought at all.
The high income threshold is $190,100. An employee earning above it cannot bring an unfair dismissal claim unless a modern award or enterprise agreement covers them — but they can still bring a general protections or breach of contract claim.
The Problem
Termination disputes are assessed under the Fair Work Act 2009, with the Fair Work Commission focused heavily on whether a fair process was followed — not just whether the underlying reason was valid. Getting the process right is often what determines the outcome.
Unless it’s serious misconduct, the Fair Work Commission expects a clear warning and a genuine opportunity to improve before dismissal — and expects it in writing, not just recalled from memory.
Notice periods under the NES scale with length of service, and awards or contracts can require more. Getting this wrong — or paying in lieu incorrectly — creates immediate underpayment exposure.
Dismissing without notice for “serious misconduct” is only lawful in genuinely serious cases. Getting this call wrong turns a clean termination into an unfair dismissal claim.
What’s said in the termination meeting itself is often used as evidence. An unscripted, emotional conversation can undo months of otherwise solid documentation.
How We Help
Fair Work Centre helps Australian employers plan and execute terminations — performance, conduct or otherwise — in a way that’s defensible if it’s ever challenged.
How It Works
Call 1300 161 828 or book a free initial advice call before you say anything to the employee.
We review your grounds, documentation and proposed process end-to-end.
Get compliant documentation and a script for a clean, defensible termination.
A short advice call now can prevent a costly unfair dismissal claim later.
Membership
The Legal Test
The Commission asks two separate questions. First, was there a valid reason for the dismissal, related to the employee’s capacity, conduct or the operational requirements of the business? Second, was the employee afforded procedural fairness — were they told what the problem was, given the evidence, and given a genuine opportunity to respond before the decision was made?
Conduct (misconduct, breach of policy), capacity (skill, performance, illness that cannot be accommodated) or genuine redundancy. It must be sound, defensible and well founded — not an after-the-fact justification for a decision already made.
Notice of the specific allegations, the evidence that supports them, a real chance to respond, a support person if requested, an unbiased decision-maker, and a decision communicated in writing with reasons.
The Commission weighs the evidence. Contemporaneous notes, dated warnings and signed records carry far more weight than a summary written after the fact. Our unfair dismissal defence guide covers how the evidence is tested.
Employees must also qualify to bring a claim: they need to have completed the minimum employment period, be covered by an award or agreement or earn under $190,100, and lodge within 21 days. We check eligibility before advising on the dismissal itself.
Notice
Section 117 sets the minimum notice an employer must give. Notice runs from the day it is given, and service continues to accrue during the notice period, which affects leave and redundancy entitlements.
| Period of continuous service | Minimum notice |
|---|---|
| One year or less | 1 week |
| More than 1 year, up to 3 years | 2 weeks |
| More than 3 years, up to 5 years | 3 weeks |
| More than 5 years | 4 weeks |
| Employee 45 or older with at least 2 years’ service | Add 1 week |
You can pay the employee instead of having them work out the notice, unless a modern award or enterprise agreement excludes payment in lieu. Payment in lieu must equal what the employee would have earned, including allowances and loadings they would have received. Underpaying notice is one of the most common technical breaches we see, and it is recoverable through the Commission and the Ombudsman.
Awards can add obligations the NES does not: consultation before a change, specific notice clauses, or restrictions on when notice can end. Our termination documents templates include the notice calculator and letter wording.
Process
This is the sequence that survives review. Skipping a step is what turns a sound decision into a compensation payment.
Write down whether this is conduct, capacity or redundancy. If it is performance, you need a documented history. If it is conduct, you need evidence of what happened, not a summary of your impression.
Has the employee served the minimum employment period? Are they award or agreement covered, or under the high income threshold? Are they on a visa with specific obligations?
Warnings, performance plans, investigation notes, meeting records and prior conversations. If the file is thin, fix that before you act — not after.
Notice clauses, consultation requirements, disciplinary procedures and any enterprise agreement steps all bind you. Follow the instrument, not a generic template.
Give the employee the specific allegations or performance concerns, the evidence, and a date to respond. A show cause letter is the record that proves the opportunity existed.
Offer a support person, give reasonable time, and actually consider what they say. A response period of two hours is not a fair hearing.
An unbiased decision-maker weighs the response against the evidence and records the reasons. If the response changes the picture, change the decision.
Hold the meeting privately, confirm the decision and effective date in writing, calculate notice and final pay, and provide the separation certificate and final payslip.
Where a dismissal for conduct involves disputed facts, an investigation usually sits between steps three and five. Our workplace investigations guide sets out that process, and performance management covers the warning and improvement sequence for capacity cases.
Misconduct
Summary dismissal means ending employment without notice because the conduct is so serious that continuing the employment relationship is impossible. It is not a shortcut for a difficult decision — the employer must still be able to prove the conduct on the balance of probabilities and still follow a fair process.
Theft or fraud, physical violence or threats, serious safety breaches, intoxication at work, harassment or sexual harassment, and refusing a lawful and reasonable direction.
One instance of poor performance, a single instance of rudeness, a disagreement with a manager, or conduct outside work unless it damages the employment relationship or the business’s reputation.
Even in a clear-cut case, give the employee the allegations and a chance to respond. An employee dismissed without any opportunity to explain is exposed on procedural grounds even where the conduct is proven.
Redundancy
A redundancy is genuine when the employer no longer requires the employee’s job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements of the business, and the requirements of any modern award or enterprise agreement about consultation have been complied with. Redeployment within the business or an associated entity must be considered first.
Two failures account for most redundancy claims: no genuine consultation, and a selection process that cannot be explained. Redundancy pay follows the NES scale, and small business employers with fewer than 15 employees are generally not required to pay it. Our redundancy advice guide covers the consultation steps and the payment scale in detail.
Final Pay
Final pay is due on the day employment ends, or within the period the award or agreement allows. Getting it wrong creates a separate claim that sits alongside any dismissal claim.
| Must be paid | Not payable |
|---|---|
| Wages up to and including the last day | Unused sick or carer’s leave |
| Accrued annual leave, plus leave loading where applicable | Future bonuses, unless contractual |
| Notice, or payment in lieu of notice | Unapproved unpaid leave |
| Redundancy pay, where applicable | Long service leave where the qualifying period is not met |
| Superannuation on ordinary time earnings | Amounts paid in lieu of unused leave (not OTE) |
Our payroll compliance page covers record keeping for terminations, and free employment documents includes the final pay checklist.
Small Business
Employers with fewer than 15 employees are covered by the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. If the employer complied with the Code, the dismissal is not unfair. The Code is a defence, not a licence — it requires a reasonable belief, based on evidence, that the employee’s conduct was serious enough to justify immediate dismissal, and it requires the employee to have been warned about the conduct and given a chance to respond before a dismissal for performance or conduct.
If you are unsure whether you meet the definition, our HR best practice guide explains how headcount is counted across associated entities.
Risk
A decision made in a Monday meeting and documented on Thursday is the single most common fatal flaw in the file.
Telling an employee they were “not meeting expectations” gives them nothing to respond to — and the Commission nothing to find fair.
Unreasonable refusal damages the credibility of the whole process, especially in sexual harassment or safety matters.
Replacing the employee, or a performance problem dressed up as a restructure, converts a lawful restructure into an unfair dismissal.
Withholding leave or notice to “settle” a dispute invites a second claim and a penalty.
An employer response to an unfair dismissal claim is due within 7 days. Missing it hands the Commission an easy finding.
Common Questions
Generally no, except in cases of serious misconduct such as theft, violence or serious safety breaches. For performance or ordinary conduct issues, the Fair Work Commission expects at least one clear, documented warning and a genuine opportunity to improve before termination.
Under the National Employment Standards, notice ranges from 1 to 4 weeks based on length of service, plus an extra week if the employee is over 45 with at least 2 years’ service. Awards, contracts or agreements may specify longer periods, so always check the highest applicable entitlement.
Summary dismissal means ending employment immediately, without notice, due to serious misconduct. It’s a high bar — the conduct must be serious enough that continuing the employment relationship even briefly would be unreasonable. Getting this wrong exposes you to both an unfair dismissal claim and a notice pay claim.
An employee generally has 21 days from the date of dismissal to lodge an unfair dismissal application with the Fair Work Commission. Extensions are only granted in exceptional circumstances, so respond to any post-termination correspondence promptly.
Unfair dismissal protection is based on the minimum employment period — 6 months for most employers, 12 months for small businesses (fewer than 15 employees) — not whether the employee is technically “on probation.” An employee under probation but past the minimum period can still bring a claim.
Keep it brief, factual and consistent with your documented reasons — avoid over-explaining, apologising in a way that implies fault, or departing from the process you’ve followed. What’s said in this meeting is frequently relied on as evidence if the termination is later challenged.
No. Fair Work Centre is an independent private advisory service for employers. We are not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.
From the Blog
Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.