Employers: Facing an issue or have a question? Get free initial guidance.

Fair Work Centre — For Employers

Workplace Investigations: How Employers Run a Process That Survives the Fair Work Commission

A workplace investigation is a documented inquiry into an allegation of misconduct, bullying, harassment or a policy breach, and how you run it matters as much as the outcome. Australian employers need written allegations, a fair hearing and evidence-based findings — because the Fair Work Commission reviews the process, not just the decision.

Australian HR manager conducting a workplace investigation interview

Not a government body
Employer-side advice only
Direct lawyer access — no call centres
Fair Work Commission representation

The Problem

A Botched Investigation Creates More Risk Than the Original Complaint

Workplace investigations need to meet the procedural fairness standard the Fair Work Commission applies when reviewing disciplinary decisions — and any related safety concerns must also be managed in line with obligations enforced by the Fair Work Ombudsman.

1

Procedural fairness isn’t optional

Every person involved needs to know the allegations against them and have a genuine chance to respond. Skip this and any resulting disciplinary action becomes vulnerable to challenge.

2

Bias, real or perceived, undermines everything

An investigator with a personal stake in the outcome — or who’s simply too close to the people involved — can invalidate findings, even if the conclusion itself was correct.

3

Confidentiality breaches create new complaints

Poorly managed investigations often generate a second complaint about how information was handled — turning one problem into two.

4

Delay is its own risk

Sitting on a complaint too long exposes the business to ongoing harm claims and signals the matter wasn’t taken seriously — both work against you if it’s ever scrutinised.

How We Help

A Defensible Investigation From Start to Finish

Fair Work Centre helps Australian employers scope, run and conclude workplace investigations that stand up to scrutiny — whether the complaint involves bullying, harassment, misconduct or a policy breach.

  • Assess whether a formal investigation is warranted
  • Define the scope of allegations and appoint an appropriate investigator
  • Guide procedurally fair interview and evidence-gathering processes
  • Advise on confidentiality and support obligations throughout
  • Prepare findings and recommendations that hold up if challenged
  • Advise on appropriate disciplinary outcomes based on findings
  • Represent your business if the outcome is disputed

Evidence

Evidence and Record Keeping in a Workplace Investigation

An investigation is only as good as its file. The Commission does not expect a perfect process, but it does expect the process to be visible: what was alleged, who was asked, what they said, and why the finding followed.

Evidence How to handle it
The complaint Recorded in the complainant’s words, dated, and acknowledged in writing to them
Witness accounts Interviewed separately, notes signed or confirmed by email, questions open rather than leading
Documents and messages Collected in original form with metadata preserved, not screenshots pasted into a document
The response of the person accused Allegations put in writing in advance, with time to respond and the right to a support person
Interview notes Contemporaneous, dated, with attendees and who said what. A summary written weeks later is worth very little
Findings and reasons A short written report: allegation, evidence, finding on the balance of probabilities, and the reason

Keep the file for seven years. Store it separately from the personnel file where the subject of the complaint can access it.

Confidentiality is an obligation, not a gag. Tell participants not to discuss the matter, but do not promise absolute secrecy you cannot deliver, and never ask a complainant to stay silent about an allegation of sexual harassment or a safety risk.

Outcomes

Investigation Outcomes: Findings, Discipline and Fairness

The investigation establishes facts. A separate decision then determines what follows. Separating the two is what makes the outcome defensible.

1

Report the findings to the decision-maker

Not the investigator’s opinion of the person, but findings on each allegation with the evidence relied on.

2

Put the findings to the employee

Before any sanction, give the employee the findings and a genuine opportunity to respond to them.

3

Consider the full context

Length of service, prior record, consistency with how similar matters were handled, and any mitigating circumstances.

4

Apply a proportionate outcome

Counsel and training, a warning, a final warning, or termination. A sanction that is harsher than comparable past cases invites a claim.

5

Confirm in writing

The findings, the outcome, the reasons and any expectations going forward. Templates sit in our termination documents.

6

Close the loop with the complainant

Tell them the matter was investigated and that action has been taken, without disclosing confidential details of the sanction.

The process

Workplace Investigation Process: 8 Steps Employers Must Document

There is no prescribed format for a workplace investigation in Australia, but the Fair Work Commission examines whether the process was fair and the decision was based on evidence. These eight steps are what a defensible investigation looks like from the inside.

  1. Record the complaint. Note the date it was raised, who raised it, precisely what is alleged, and who witnessed it. Memory is not evidence, and the record starts here.
  2. Assess whether a formal investigation is needed. Bullying, harassment, serious misconduct and safety allegations call for a formal process. Minor interpersonal friction can often be managed informally. Record the reasoning either way, because consistency across complaints is what the Commission tests.
  3. Appoint the investigator and check for conflicts. The investigator should have no involvement in the events, no reporting line to either party, and no prior view on the outcome. Where the business is small, an external investigator is usually the safer path.
  4. Notify the employee in writing. Set out the specific allegations, the process being followed, the evidence that will be considered, and their right to bring a support person. Vague allegations such as “misconduct” deny the employee a fair hearing.
  5. Gather evidence and interview witnesses. Preserve documents, emails and rosters before anything is deleted. Take dated statements, and confirm interview notes with each person afterwards.
  6. Put the findings to the employee. This is the step employers most often skip. Before any decision is made, the employee must see the substance of the evidence against them and have a genuine opportunity to respond to it.
  7. Decide on the balance of probabilities. For each allegation, record a finding of substantiated, partly substantiated or not substantiated, with the reasons and the evidence relied on.
  8. Implement and document the outcome. Communicate the decision and the consequences in writing, then keep the record. Employment records relating to termination must be kept for seven years.

If the outcome is dismissal, the clock matters: an employee has 21 days from the date of dismissal to lodge an unfair dismissal claim with the Fair Work Commission.

The legal test

Procedural Fairness: Notice, a Fair Hearing and an Unbiased Decision-Maker

Procedural fairness in a workplace investigation has two limbs. The employee must be told, in specific terms, what they are accused of. And they must be given a real opportunity to answer it before a decision is made. When the Fair Work Commission reviews a dismissal, it weighs whether there was a valid reason and whether the employee was given that opportunity to respond.

The failures we see most often are predictable: the outcome was decided before the interviews; the investigator gathered the evidence and then delivered the punishment; the employee was never shown the witness statements; no support person was offered; or a long-serving employee with an unblemished record was treated identically to a recent hire. Any one of those can turn a substantiated allegation into an unfair dismissal.

There is a second exposure running alongside it. Taking adverse action against an employee because they made a complaint, exercised a workplace right or raised a safety issue can found a general protections claim, which carries no statutory compensation cap. The procedural fairness standard is what keeps both risks contained, and it is judged on the documents you can produce afterwards, not on how well the meeting went.

Managing the workplace

When to Suspend an Employee During an Investigation

Suspension during an investigation is a neutral act to protect the process, not a disciplinary outcome. Unless a contract, award or enterprise agreement allows otherwise, a suspended employee should stay on full pay, because an unpaid suspension imposed before any finding is made can itself be treated as a dismissal.

Suspending on pay is usually justified where the employee could interfere with evidence or witnesses, where other employees or customers are at risk, or where the allegations involve violence, theft or serious safety breaches. Where the risk is lower, consider alternatives: changed duties, a different location, a temporary reporting-line change, or clear written instructions about contact with witnesses. Whatever you choose, put the reason in writing, review the arrangement every week or two, and end it as soon as it is no longer needed.

If the investigation leads to termination, the way the decision is communicated matters as much as the decision itself. Our termination of employment guide sets out the notice, final pay and process requirements, and our unfair dismissal defence page covers what to do once a claim is filed.

Key Facts Every Employer Should Know

2
Core elements of procedural fairness: notice and a fair hearing
0
Tolerance the FWC has for investigator bias or conflict of interest
21 days
Window to challenge a dismissal resulting from a flawed process
3
Typical outcome categories: substantiated, unsubstantiated, inconclusive

How It Works

Get Advice in Three Steps

1

Call or enquire

Call 1300 161 828 or book a free initial advice call as soon as a complaint is raised.

2

Speak to a dedicated lawyer

We help you scope the investigation and decide who should run it.

3

Resolve with confidence

Get a fair, well-documented process and a defensible outcome.

Don’t Let a Complaint Become a Claim

A short advice call now can prevent a flawed process becoming a much bigger problem.

Membership

Plans Built for Ongoing Employer Protection

Standard
$118/month
  • 50+ HR document templates
  • Investigation process guides
  • Self-service HR resources

See Plan Details

Professional
$346/month
  • Everything in Advanced
  • Unlimited lawyer advice sessions
  • Fair Work Commission representation

See Plan Details

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Not every complaint requires a full formal investigation, but you do need a consistent, documented process for assessing each one. Ignoring a serious complaint — bullying, harassment or safety related — creates significant legal and reputational risk regardless of how the investigation is ultimately scoped.

The investigator needs to be impartial and free of any real or perceived conflict of interest. For smaller businesses or complaints involving senior staff, an external investigator is often the safer choice to protect the integrity of the outcome.

Procedural fairness means the person accused knows the substance of the allegations against them and has a genuine opportunity to respond before any findings or disciplinary action are finalised. Skipping this step is one of the most common reasons investigation outcomes are successfully challenged.

Yes, in appropriate cases you can stand an employee down on pay while an investigation is conducted, particularly where there’s a safety risk or risk of evidence interference. This should be framed as a neutral precaution, not a punishment, and should be time-limited.

There’s no fixed legal timeframe, but investigations should be completed as promptly as reasonably possible given the complexity of the allegations. Unreasonable delay can itself become a source of complaint and undermine confidence in the process.

An unsubstantiated finding means there wasn’t enough evidence to support the allegation — it doesn’t necessarily mean the complaint was made in bad faith. Both parties should be informed of the outcome appropriately, and any ongoing workplace relationship issues should still be managed constructively.

No. Fair Work Centre is an independent private advisory service for employers. We are not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

From the Blog

Latest Articles on Workplace Investigations

Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

Free Initial Legal Guidance For Employers

Speak to an Employment Lawyer at Fair Work Centre

To change or request cancellation of your Client Membership, please email us with your request at: info@fairworkcentre.com.au.

Refer to our Terms of Service for changes or cancellation requests.

Request Call Back

Employers / HR Managers:  1300 161 828
Employees / Workers:  13 13 94

If you would like more information about any of our professional products or services, feel free to contact us, or simply fill in our enquiry form.

You must be logged in to submit this form