Employers: Facing an issue or have a question? Get free initial guidance.

Fair Work Centre — For Employers

Commissions, Contractors and Underperforming Agents — Advice for Real Estate Agencies

Commission structures, contractor disputes and restraint clauses on departure create distinct employment law risk for real estate and property management businesses. Get advice built for your agency.

Australian real estate agency principal reviewing employment contracts

Not a government body
Employer-side advice only
Direct lawyer access — no call centres
Fair Work Commission representation

Real Estate Guide

Real Estate Employment Law: Commission Structures, Weekend Work and Agent Exits

Real estate runs on a pay model that most industries never touch: commission-only agreements, retainer plus commission, vehicle allowances, and weekend opens that fall outside any ordinary week. Each is lawful with the right structure, and each becomes an underpayment or a claim without it.

The industry’s recurring disputes are not about hourly rates. They are about whether a commission-only arrangement was valid, whether an agent was an employee or a contractor, whether a departing agent took clients, and whether a property manager was on call every weekend without being paid for it.

Commission-only
Permitted only within strict award limits, not as a default for new starters
$190,100
High income threshold for unfair dismissal, where no award covers the employee
7 years
How long commission records, timesheets and pay records must be kept

The high income threshold does not remove award coverage. A sales agent covered by the Real Estate Industry Award can bring an unfair dismissal claim at any income.

The Problem

Real Estate Agencies Face Risk in How Agents Are Engaged and Paid

Whether an agent is genuinely an employee or a contractor is scrutinised closely under the Fair Work Act 2009, and commission-only arrangements must still meet minimum entitlement guarantees enforced by the Fair Work Ombudsman.

1

Contractor vs employee disputes over commission agents

Treating a genuinely controlled, business-integrated agent as a contractor to avoid minimum entitlements is one of the most common and costly misclassification risks in real estate.

2

Commission-only structures still need a wage floor

Even where pay is commission-based, employees are still entitled to minimum guarantees under the applicable award — a bad month for sales doesn’t remove this obligation.

3

Restraint clauses on agent departure are often unenforceable

Poorly drafted non-compete and non-solicitation clauses offer little real protection when a top-performing agent leaves and takes a client list with them.

4

Managing underperforming agents

Performance issues tied to sales targets need a fair, documented process — target-based dismissals without proper process are a common source of unfair dismissal claims.

How We Help

Employment Advice Built for Agencies and Property Managers

Fair Work Centre helps real estate and property management businesses manage agent classification, commission structure compliance and enforceable exit clauses.

Our advice reflects current Fair Work Commission guidance on commission-based employment and restraint of trade enforceability.

  • Assess agent classification to avoid contractor misclassification risk
  • Confirm commission structures meet minimum entitlement guarantees
  • Draft enforceable restraint of trade and non-solicitation clauses
  • Advise on managing underperformance against sales targets
  • Draft compliant employment contracts for agents and property managers
  • Advise on redundancy during agency mergers or office closures
  • Represent your agency in Fair Work Commission matters

How It Works

Get Advice in Three Steps

1

Call or enquire

Call 1300 161 828 or book a free initial advice call about your business.

2

Speak to a dedicated lawyer

We review your specific classification, contracts and compliance risk.

3

Resolve with confidence

Get a clear compliance plan built for your business and workforce.

Get Your Agent Contracts and Commission Structure Right

A short advice call now can prevent a misclassified agent or unenforceable restraint costing you later.

Membership

Plans Built for Ongoing Employer Protection

Standard
$118/month
  • 50+ HR document templates
  • Employment agreement templates
  • Self-service HR resources

See Plan Details

Professional
$346/month
  • Everything in Advanced
  • Unlimited lawyer advice sessions
  • Fair Work Commission representation

See Plan Details

Coverage

Which Award Covers Your Agency

Role Award that usually covers it The trap
Sales agent and representative Real Estate Industry Award Commission-only applied to a new starter who is not eligible for it
Property manager Real Estate Industry Award After-hours calls and weekend inspections treated as part of the salary
Administration and reception Clerks coverage in many cases Admin staff paid on agency-specific arrangements with no award basis
Buyer’s agent or contractor Depends on characterisation Commission-only contractor who is rostered and supervised like an employee
Trust accounting staff Clerks coverage in many cases No coverage determination recorded

Record the determination per role. See modern awards compliance.

Commission

Commission-Only and Retainer Structures

Commission-only pay is not a general option. Under the award it is confined to experienced sales employees who meet specific income and experience conditions, with a written agreement that complies with the award’s requirements.

Eligibility for commission-only

New starters and less experienced agents are generally entitled to a retainer or wage. Applying commission-only from day one is the most common real estate underpayment.

Written agreement

The arrangement must be recorded in the form the award requires, signed, and reviewed when the employee’s circumstances change. See employment contracts.

Retainer plus commission

Where a retainer is paid, it must at least meet the award minimum for the classification, with commission on top rather than replacing it.

Commission calculations

Statements showing how each commission was calculated, issued at payment. Verbal promises about splits are the basis of most disputes.

Weekends

Weekend Opens, After-Hours Inspections and Overtime

Real estate work happens when buyers and tenants are available, which is evenings and Saturdays. Whether that is payable depends on the award, not on the fact that the industry has always worked that way.

  • ✓ Rostered hours reflect the days and times actually worked, including Saturday opens
  • ✓ Overtime or time off in lieu applied where hours exceed ordinary hours
  • ✓ Weekend and public holiday work attracts the loadings the award specifies
  • ✓ A vehicle allowance is paid where the award requires it and the employee uses their own car
  • ✓ After-hours phone availability for property managers is either rostered and paid, or genuinely voluntary
  • ✗ A salary that assumes every Saturday without reconciliation
  • ✗ Property managers on call every weekend at no additional pay
  • ✗ Overtime accumulating with no TOIL recorded
  • ✗ Vehicle costs absorbed by the employee with no allowance

Characterisation

Contractor Agents vs Employees

Some agencies engage sales staff as contractors on commission splits. That structure only holds where the agent genuinely runs their own business.

Points to contractor Points to employment
Sets own hours and works from own office Required to attend the agency’s office and meetings
Pays own licence, insurance and marketing Agency provides desk, systems, branding and leads
Keeps own records and invoices Agency controls CRM, listings and client contact
Free to work for other agencies Exclusivity required in practice
Bears the risk of no sale Agency guarantees a retainer regardless of sales

Mischaracterised agents create exposure for superannuation, leave entitlements and unpaid minimum rates across the whole engagement.

Restraints

Client Portability and Restraints

Real estate restraints are common and frequently unenforceable, because they are drafted broader than the legitimate interest they protect.

What is protectable

Client relationships and confidential information: vendor and landlord databases, appraisal pipelines, and pricing data.

What is not

A blanket ban on working within 50 kilometres for two years. Period, area and activity must each be reasonable for the role.

Evidence that decides it

Records showing client lists downloaded, emails forwarded, or appraisals arranged before the resignation. Documentary evidence wins these matters.

Practical alternative

A notice period with garden leave, and well-drafted confidentiality terms, are usually more effective than an aggressive restraint.

Exit

Handling a Departing Agent

1

Check the contract and restraint first

Before the exit is announced. Whether you can hold the agent to notice and restraint shapes everything else.

2

Confirm commission entitlements

Which sales were written, exchanged or settled before the last day, and how the scheme allocates them. See payroll compliance.

3

Secure client data

Trust records, CRM access, listings and keys. Revoke access on the day, documented.

4

Give notice or payment in lieu correctly

Per contract and the NES. Getting this wrong converts a clean exit into a claim. See termination of employment.

5

If you are dismissing, run a proper process

Allegations in writing, an opportunity to respond, and a documented decision. See unfair dismissal defence.

6

Watch for the protected reason

A commission dispute or a complaint about pay is a workplace right. See general protections.

Admin Roles

Trust Accounting, Reception and Admin Roles

The roles that never appear in a sales meeting are the ones that generate the compliance findings. Trust accounting and reception staff handle money, records and client data, and their employment arrangements carry obligations the award does not assume.

Classification is usually the clerks award

Reception, admin and trust accounting roles generally fall under clerks coverage rather than the real estate award. Applying agent classifications to admin staff is a recording error that compounds weekly.

Trust account access is a licensed function

Only authorised people should have trust account access. Unauthorised access is a regulatory breach as well as a supervision failure, and it belongs in the position description.

Money never touches wages

Bonds, deposits and rental payments must never be deducted from pay or held against wages. Deductions require written authorisation under the Fair Work Act, and there is no exception for agency money.

Confidentiality and conflicts

Staff who can see vendor and landlord databases hold confidential information. Access should be role-based, logged, and revoked the day someone leaves.

After Hours

Property Management: After-Hours Contact and Records

Property management is on call by design: tenant emergencies, trade coordination and landlord calls happen outside office hours. Whether that is paid depends on how it is structured, not on how long it has been done that way.

Situation What it usually means
Rostered after-hours phone Rostered time, paid as ordinary hours or a loading depending on the award
Emergency attendance Work time, including call-out minimums where the award provides them
Coordinating trades remotely Work time where the employee is required to act, even from home
Genuinely voluntary availability Not work time, provided there is no expectation, penalty or consequence for declining
Condition reports and entries Work time, whether performed in the office or on site

The evidence question is simple: is there a roster, and is there a record? If the phone is handed around a team with no roster and no timesheet, the hours are unrecorded and the employee’s account will be preferred.

  • ✓ After-hours duties are rostered, with the roster retained
  • ✓ Hours worked outside ordinary hours are recorded, not reconstructed later
  • ✓ On-call or call-out payments applied where the award requires them
  • ✓ Vehicle allowance where the employee uses their own car for inspections and attendances
  • ✓ Declining an after-hours call carries no adverse consequence, so availability is genuinely voluntary
  • ✗ A phone passed around informally with no roster
  • ✗ Overtime absorbed into a salary that was never reconciled
  • ✗ Attendance at emergencies treated as part of a fixed salary
  • ✗ Vehicle costs absorbed by the property manager

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

It depends on the substance of the relationship — the level of control the agency exercises, whether the agent works exclusively for you, and who bears the financial risk — not the label used in the agreement.

Employees on commission structures are generally still entitled to a minimum wage guarantee under the applicable award, regardless of sales performance in a given period.

They can be, but only to the extent reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest like client relationships — overly broad clauses are commonly narrowed or struck down.

Yes, but it needs to follow a fair process — clear expectations, a genuine opportunity to improve, and proper documentation — rather than an immediate dismissal based on one bad period.

This is exactly what a properly drafted restraint and confidentiality clause is designed to address — without one, protecting client relationships becomes far harder.

Property managers are typically salaried or wage-based rather than commission-based, and are generally covered by the Real Estate Industry Award with standard entitlements applying.

No. Fair Work Centre is an independent private advisory service for employers. We are not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

From the Blog

Latest Employer Guides for Real Estate

Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

Free Initial Legal Guidance For Employers

Speak to an Employment Lawyer at Fair Work Centre

To change or request cancellation of your Client Membership, please email us with your request at: info@fairworkcentre.com.au.

Refer to our Terms of Service for changes or cancellation requests.

Request Call Back

Employers / HR Managers:  1300 161 828
Employees / Workers:  13 13 94

If you would like more information about any of our professional products or services, feel free to contact us, or simply fill in our enquiry form.

You must be logged in to submit this form