Fair Work Centre — For Employers
A genuine redundancy is a legal test, not a label. Get expert advice on selection criteria, consultation and payouts so your redundancy holds up if it’s ever challenged.
Employer Guide
A redundancy is lawful when the employer no longer requires the job to be performed by anyone because of operational changes, has complied with any consultation obligation in a modern award or enterprise agreement, and it was not reasonable to redeploy the employee elsewhere in the business or an associated entity. Miss any one of those three and the dismissal is not a genuine redundancy, which means the employee can bring an unfair dismissal claim.
Redundancy is about the role disappearing, not about the person holding it. Performance problems, personality clashes and workplace complaints dressed up as restructuring are the most common reason the Fair Work Commission overturns a redundancy, and the exposure is real: up to $95,050 in compensation, plus the cost of replacing the process with a lawful one.
The high income threshold is $190,100. An employee above it cannot bring an unfair dismissal claim unless a modern award or enterprise agreement covers them, but redundancy pay under the National Employment Standards is still owed regardless of earnings.
The Problem
Redundancy must meet the “genuine redundancy” test under the Fair Work Act 2009 — the role must no longer be required, consultation obligations must be met, and redeployment must be considered. Missing any of these elements exposes even a well-intentioned redundancy to an unfair dismissal or general protections claim.
If the role isn’t genuinely no longer required, or you don’t follow consultation obligations under the applicable award or agreement, the Fair Work Commission can find it wasn’t a genuine redundancy at all.
Choosing who to make redundant based on unclear or inconsistent criteria opens the door to unfair dismissal and general protections claims — especially if performance, age or leave history factor in.
Employers must genuinely consider redeployment within the business (or associated entities) before finalising a redundancy — skipping this step is a common and costly failure point.
Redundancy pay under the NES scales up to 16 weeks based on continuous service. Miscalculating it — or missing notice period obligations — creates immediate underpayment exposure.
How We Help
Fair Work Centre helps Australian employers plan and execute redundancies that meet the genuine redundancy test — protecting the business from unfair dismissal and general protections risk while treating departing staff fairly.
Our advice reflects current Fair Work Commission guidance on genuine redundancy and consultation obligations.
How It Works
Call 1300 161 828 or book a free initial advice call before you announce anything.
We review your structure, award coverage and proposed selection criteria.
Get correct calculations, compliant documentation and a defensible process.
A short advice call now can prevent a costly unfair dismissal claim later.
Membership
The Three Tests
The Commission does not ask whether the business decision was wise. It asks three narrower questions, and the employer carries the burden of answering all three.
There must be a real operational change: lower volume, closure, restructure, new technology or a genuine reduction in the work required. Replacing the person and calling it redundancy fails this test immediately.
If a modern award or enterprise agreement requires consultation, you must actually do it, before the decision is final. Announcing first and discussing afterwards is the most common failure we see.
You must look for another role within the business and any associated entity. If a reasonable alternative existed and you did not offer it, the redundancy is not genuine.
Redundancy cannot be used to remove an employee for exercising a workplace right, taking leave, making a complaint or being injured. Those cases move from unfair dismissal into general protections, where compensation is uncapped.
Redundancy Pay
Redundancy pay is calculated on continuous service and the employee’s base rate of pay. The scale runs from four weeks at one year to twelve weeks at ten years, and it does not keep climbing after that.
Scale under section 119 of the Fair Work Act 2009. Base rate of pay only: overtime, penalties, loadings and allowances are excluded.
Employers with fewer than 15 employees are not required to pay redundancy pay under the NES. That exemption does not remove the consultation obligation in the award, and it does not make the redundancy any less subject to the genuine redundancy tests.
Process
This is the sequence that survives review. The mistake is almost never the business decision; it is announcing it before the sequence is complete.
Write down what changed: lost contract, reduced demand, restructure, automation. Date it before the announcement, because a rationale written afterwards reads exactly like one written afterwards.
Most modern awards require you to notify and consult affected employees and their representatives before the decision is final. The clause is specific about timing and who must be involved.
Start from the positions that are disappearing. Build the new structure on paper first. If the list of roles maps one-to-one to the people you wanted to remove, the redundancy will not survive scrutiny.
Where several employees hold the same role, use criteria you can evidence: skills, qualifications, experience, disciplinary history, performance records. Score them and keep the matrix.
Explain the change, the roles affected, the reasons, and invite alternatives. Consider what comes back. Consultation means the outcome can still change, not that you are informing people of one.
Look across the business and any associated entity for suitable roles, including roles at a lower grade or different location where that is reasonable. Record the search and why each role was or was not suitable.
Redundancy pay, notice or payment in lieu, accrued annual leave with loading, long service leave where applicable and any award entitlements. Check each one separately; they have different rules.
Deliver the news privately, provide the written notice, explain the payments and the timetable, and offer an employee assistance contact. Give the person time to ask questions and to take advice.
Consultation
Consultation is where most redundancies fail, and it fails on timing rather than paperwork. The obligation is to consult before you have committed to the outcome.
Notify the employees affected and any union or representative they nominate, give them the relevant information, discuss the change and its effect, and give genuine consideration to alternatives before the decision is made.
Two-way discussion with a real possibility of a different outcome. If the roles were already finalised, minutes describing a discussion will not rescue the process.
The consultation clause itself, the notice given, meeting notes, the alternatives raised and your response to each. If it is not written down, the Commission will treat it as not having happened.
Selection
Selection is the second most litigated part of a redundancy, because it is where a legitimate restructure starts to look like a targeted exit.
Objective criteria must be applied consistently across the pool, scored, and retained. A mix of criteria applied only to some employees is treated as a selection made in advance.
If the person you plan to make redundant has recently complained, been injured or taken leave, get advice before you act. A redundancy that follows a workplace right is a general protections risk, and there is no compensation cap in that jurisdiction.
Redeployment
The third test is the one employers most often skip. If a reasonable alternative role existed and you did not offer it, the redundancy is not genuine, regardless of how sound the business case was.
Reasonable is judged on the role and the person: similar duties, comparable pay, workable location, the employee’s skills and any training that could close a small gap, and the employee’s personal circumstances. It covers associated entities, not just your own payroll, so a related company with an opening is part of the search.
Entitlements
Final pay on a redundancy is several calculations running at once, and each has its own rule. Paying the right total but the wrong components still leaves you exposed.
Redundancy pay, notice and leave are separate entitlements: an employee receives all of them, not one instead of another.
Notice and final pay rules are covered in more detail in our termination of employment guide, and the letters you need sit in the termination document templates. Final pay is also a payroll compliance obligation: an underpayment is recoverable whether or not the redundancy was genuine.
A genuine redundancy payment made to an employee under the age of 65, because the job has ended, is generally taxed concessionally up to the ATO tax-free limit, with anything above that taxed as an employment termination payment. Get the calculation right; an underpayment discovered later is a compliance issue with the Ombudsman, not just an HR one.
Mistakes
The decision is presented as final, so the consultation that follows cannot change anything. This is the single most common reason a redundancy is found not genuine.
A documented performance problem, followed by a restructure that removes only that person, looks exactly like what it is.
No record of looking for alternative roles inside the group means the third test is unmet, even if no role existed.
Choosing by manager instinct, with no matrix and no consistent criteria, invites a challenge on every ground at once.
Missing leave loading, using total pay rather than base rate, or paying notice instead of redundancy pay, are all recoverable underpayments.
Verbal conversations, undated rationale and missing minutes leave you proving a process you cannot evidence.
Common Questions
A redundancy is genuine when the employer no longer requires the role to be performed by anyone due to operational changes, the employer has complied with consultation obligations in the applicable award or agreement, and it would not have been reasonable to redeploy the employee elsewhere in the business or an associated entity.
Under the National Employment Standards, redundancy pay scales from 4 weeks (1 year of service) up to 16 weeks (12+ years of service). Businesses with fewer than 15 employees are generally exempt from NES redundancy pay, though awards or contracts may still apply their own entitlements.
Yes. The Fair Work Commission will look at whether it would have been reasonable to redeploy the employee into another role within your business or an associated entity before finalising the redundancy. Failing to genuinely consider this is one of the most common reasons redundancies are found not to be genuine.
Yes — an employee can lodge an unfair dismissal claim if they believe the redundancy wasn’t genuine, or a general protections claim if they believe they were selected for a prohibited reason. Both have strict time limits, so a clear, documented process is your best protection.
Most modern awards and enterprise agreements require employers to notify affected employees as soon as a definite decision is made, discuss the changes, their impact, and ways to minimise negative effects, and consider any matters the employee raises. Skipping consultation can undo an otherwise genuine redundancy.
Casual employees generally aren’t entitled to NES redundancy pay, but if a casual has been employed regularly and systematically, they may still bring an unfair dismissal claim if the role ends unfairly. Getting advice before ending a long-term casual engagement is strongly recommended.
No. Fair Work Centre is an independent private advisory service for employers. We are not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.
From the Blog
Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.