Employers: Facing an issue or have a question? Get free initial guidance.

Fair Work Centre — For Employers

Managing an Underperforming Employee? Do It Wrong and You’ll Own the Outcome

Performance management done properly protects your business and gives struggling employees a genuine chance to improve. Done poorly, it becomes the centrepiece of an unfair dismissal claim.

Australian manager giving feedback in a performance review meeting

Not a government body
Employer-side advice only
Direct lawyer access — no call centres
Fair Work Commission representation

Employer Guide

Performance Management in Australia: Managing the Problem Before It Becomes a Claim

Performance management is the paper trail that makes a fair decision possible. Handled properly, an underperforming employee either improves or leaves through a process that survives review. Handled badly, the same decision becomes an unfair dismissal claim, because the Commission will find there was no valid reason and no opportunity to respond.

The sequence is not complicated: a clear standard, evidence of the gap, genuine support, a written warning with a review date, and a fair chance to improve. What separates employers who win from those who settle is whether that sequence exists in writing before the final meeting.

6 or 12 months
Minimum employment period before an employee can claim unfair dismissal
$95,050
Maximum unfair dismissal compensation payable in 2026
21 days
After the dismissal takes effect, to lodge a claim

Improvement processes fail for one of two reasons: the expectation was never clear, or the warning was never issued. Both are within your control, and both are fixable before the final meeting. See employment contracts for how to set the standard at the start.

The Problem

Poor Performance Management Is the #1 Cause of Unfair Dismissal Findings

The Fair Work Commission consistently applies the same test when reviewing performance-based dismissals: was there a valid reason, and was the process fair? Both elements are assessed against the standards set out in the Fair Work Act 2009.

1

Vague feedback, vague expectations

If an employee was never told clearly what “good” looked like, or how they were falling short, the Fair Work Commission is unlikely to find their eventual dismissal was fair.

2

No genuine opportunity to improve

A performance improvement plan on paper isn’t enough — employees need a realistic timeframe, clear support, and a genuine chance to meet the standard before termination.

3

Inconsistent enforcement

Managing one underperforming employee strictly while ignoring the same issue in others opens the door to discrimination or unfair treatment claims.

4

Undocumented conversations

Verbal warnings that are never followed up in writing are effectively invisible if a dismissal is later challenged — memory alone won’t hold up as evidence.

How We Help

A Performance Process That’s Fair and Defensible

Fair Work Centre helps Australian employers build performance management processes that give employees a genuine chance to improve — while properly protecting the business if termination becomes necessary.

  • Set clear, measurable performance expectations from day one
  • Draft and structure performance improvement plans (PIPs)
  • Guide warning processes and required documentation
  • Advise on realistic improvement timeframes and support obligations
  • Prepare termination documentation if performance doesn’t improve
  • Ensure consistent application across your workforce
  • Represent your business if a termination is challenged

How It Works

Get Advice in Three Steps

1

Call or enquire

Call 1300 161 828 or book a free initial advice call before your next review meeting.

2

Speak to a dedicated lawyer

We help you set expectations and build a documented improvement process.

3

Resolve with confidence

Get a fair, well-documented process — whatever the ultimate outcome.

Set Your Performance Process Up Properly, From the Start

A short advice call now can prevent a costly unfair dismissal claim later.

Membership

Plans Built for Ongoing Employer Protection

Standard
$118/month
  • 50+ HR document templates
  • Performance improvement plan templates
  • Self-service HR resources

See Plan Details

Professional
$346/month
  • Everything in Advanced
  • Unlimited lawyer advice sessions
  • Fair Work Commission representation

See Plan Details

The Distinction

Managing Performance Is Not the Same as Dismissing for It

Capacity, not personality

Performance management addresses whether the employee can do the job: skill, effort, output, accuracy. If the real issue is attitude, conflict or conduct, use the conduct process instead.

A process, not a conversation

One difficult meeting is not performance management. The process is a sequence of dated, written steps with a review after each one.

An opportunity, not a formality

The improvement must genuinely be possible: realistic targets, training, support and enough time. A plan designed to be failed is evidence against you.

A record, not a memory

If the steps are not documented and signed, they did not happen as far as the Commission is concerned. Documentation is the entire point.

PIP

The Performance Improvement Plan That Stands Up

A PIP is not a disciplinary document, and it is not a warning in disguise. It is a structured, time-bound plan that states what must change and how improvement will be measured.

Component What a defensible version contains
The gap Specific, evidenced examples with dates: what the standard is, what happened, and the impact
The expectation What good performance looks like in measurable terms, not adjectives
Support offered Training, coaching, tools, adjusted duties, additional supervision, and who is responsible
The timeframe A defined period with check-in dates, realistic for the role
The measurement How progress will be assessed, by whom, using what data
The consequence Stated plainly: failure to improve may lead to further action, up to termination
Signatures and acknowledgement Employee signs receipt, with a right of reply recorded if they disagree

A PIP that cannot be summarised in one page is usually a document written to justify a decision already made.

Expectations

Setting Expectations: Goals, Standards and Measures

1

Start from the position description

If the duties on paper do not match reality, fix the document first. You cannot manage against a standard you have not set.

2

Make the standard measurable

Volume, accuracy, deadlines, compliance with procedure. Where judgement is involved, define what acceptable looks like with examples.

3

Confirm it in writing

A short document, agreed and signed, with a review date. Verbal expectations are the most common reason a later warning collapses.

4

Review on schedule

Keep the reviews, even when performance is fine. A consistent rhythm is what makes the eventual warning credible.

5

Separate systems from people

If several employees are missing the same target, the target or the training is the problem, not the individuals.

Warnings

Warnings and Reviews: What Goes in Writing

A warning is evidence. It should be able to be read two years later by someone who was not in the room and still make sense.

  • ✓ Date, attendees and the specific concern discussed
  • ✓ The expectation, restated, with the examples relied on
  • ✓ The employee’s response, recorded fairly and without editorialising
  • ✓ What improvement is required and by when
  • ✓ What support was offered and accepted
  • ✓ The consequence of no improvement, stated plainly
  • ✓ Review date, and the outcome recorded at that review
  • ✓ Signature or acknowledgement, with refusal noted
  • ✗ A warning that refers to ‘attitude’ or ‘not being a team player’
  • ✗ No review date, so the warning never expires and never proves anything
  • ✗ Warnings issued by one manager and never disclosed to the next
  • ✗ Escalating to a final warning without an intermediate review
  • ✗ Dismissing on a warning the employee never received

Support

Support, Adjustments and the Reasonable Employer

Before performance is treated as a capacity problem, rule out everything that is not the employee’s fault. This is what the Commission means by giving the employee a fair go.

Training and supervision

If the employee was never shown how, the performance issue is a management issue. Record what training was given and when.

Illness, injury or disability

A performance decline that coincides with an injury or a health condition is a general protections risk. Consider reasonable adjustments and medical evidence before acting.

Workload and resourcing

An unrealistic workload produces performance issues across a team. Check the data before you individualise the problem.

Caring and flexible work obligations

A refusal of a flexible work request, followed by a performance process, invites a claim that the request was the real reason.

Misconduct

When the Problem Is Actually Misconduct

Performance and conduct are different processes with different rules, and mixing them is a common way to lose a defensible case.

Performance process Conduct process
Concern is capability, effort or output Concern is behaviour or breach of policy
Improvement is possible and expected Investigation establishes what happened
PIP, support, review dates Allegations put in writing, response, findings
Warnings escalate over weeks or months Outcome may be immediate for serious misconduct
No investigation usually required Investigation records are essential
Termination only after a failed PIP Termination possible after findings and a response

A conduct issue dressed up as a performance issue is a procedural fairness problem waiting to be found.

Termination

Terminating for Performance: The Final Steps

If the process has been followed properly, the final step is a decision, not a surprise. If it would be a surprise to the employee, the process was not followed.

1

Confirm the record is complete

Signed expectations, PIP, warning, review outcomes and evidence of the continued gap.

2

Check the timing

Minimum employment period, any leave or complaint in the recent past, and whether the employee is covered by the system at all.

3

Hold a fair final meeting

State the concern and the evidence, allow a response, and offer a support person. Do not decide before it starts.

4

Confirm in writing

The reason, the effective date, notice or payment in lieu and final pay. Our termination document templates cover the letters.

5

Pay correctly and on time

Notice, accrued leave and any award entitlements. Underpayment turns a defensible dismissal into a compliance problem. See payroll compliance.

Mistakes

Common Performance Management Mistakes

No baseline

There was never a documented standard, so the gap cannot be evidenced.

Paper created at the end

Warnings drafted the week of the dismissal are obvious, and they destroy credibility.

Same manager throughout

The person who set the target, assessed it and decided the outcome is also the person who should not have finalised it alone.

PIP designed to fail

Unachievable targets within unrealistic timeframes read as a predetermined outcome.

Skipping the review

A warning with no review date proves nothing about whether improvement was possible.

Ignoring the protected reason

An injury, a complaint or a flexible work request in the background reframes the whole matter. Get advice first. Our HR best practice guide covers the systems that prevent this.

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

There’s no fixed legal number, but the Fair Work Commission generally expects at least one clear, documented warning that identifies the specific issue and a genuine opportunity to improve before dismissal. More serious or repeated issues may need more than one warning.

A solid PIP includes specific, measurable performance expectations, a realistic timeframe to improve, what support the employer will provide, and clear consequences if the standard isn’t met. It should be reviewed and documented at regular checkpoints, not just issued and forgotten.

Generally no, unless the failure is serious enough to amount to misconduct (such as a significant safety breach). Ordinary performance issues require a warning and improvement process first — skipping straight to dismissal is one of the most common reasons claims succeed.

If the PIP was genuine, well-documented, and gave a realistic opportunity to improve, dismissal at the end of an unsuccessful PIP is far more likely to be considered fair. The quality of the process matters just as much as the final decision.

You need a consistent standard and process, even if individual circumstances differ. Applying performance standards inconsistently across similar situations is a common trigger for discrimination or unfair treatment claims.

No — they’re legally distinct. Performance issues generally require a supportive improvement process, while misconduct may justify a disciplinary process or even summary dismissal in serious cases. Treating the two the same is a frequent and costly mistake.

No. Fair Work Centre is an independent private advisory service for employers. We are not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

From the Blog

Latest Articles on Managing Employees

Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority.

Free Initial Legal Guidance For Employers

Speak to an Employment Lawyer at Fair Work Centre

To change or request cancellation of your Client Membership, please email us with your request at: info@fairworkcentre.com.au.

Refer to our Terms of Service for changes or cancellation requests.

Request Call Back

Employers / HR Managers:  1300 161 828
Employees / Workers:  13 13 94

If you would like more information about any of our professional products or services, feel free to contact us, or simply fill in our enquiry form.

You must be logged in to submit this form