Employers: Facing an issue or have a question? Get free initial guidance.

Terminating an Injured Employee: When Can You Fire an Employee After an Injury?

Terminating an injured employee — employer reviewing dismissal risks with an employment lawyer

Quick Summary

Quick Summary

  • You can lawfully dismiss an injured worker only where the injury, absence or compensation claim plays no genuine part in the reason — and the file proves it.
  • Adverse action compensation is uncapped; unfair dismissal compensation is capped at $95,050, half the $190,100 high income threshold from 1 July 2026.
  • A dismissed employee has 21 days to lodge an unfair dismissal claim with the Fair Work Commission.
  • State schemes add protections — in NSW it is an offence to dismiss within 52 weeks of injury solely or principally because of the injury.
  • Get the decision file and legal review in place before dismissing, not after.

Terminating an injured employee is one of the highest-risk dismissal decisions an Australian employer can make. Yes, you can lawfully end the employment of an injured worker — but only where the injury, the absence or their workers compensation claim plays no part in your reasons, and you can prove it. Dismiss an employee because they are injured or on compo and you face an uncapped general protections claim before the Fair Work Commission, on top of an unfair dismissal claim worth up to $95,050 in compensation.

Two layers of law apply: the Fair Work Act 2009 (adverse action, discrimination, unfair dismissal, notice) and your state workers compensation scheme, which adds its own dismissal protections. This guide covers when dismissal of an injured worker is lawful, the penalties when it is not, and the safe process to follow.

Can You Terminate an Injured Employee?

There is no absolute prohibition on ending employment while a worker is injured or on workers compensation — what the law prohibits is the reason. Making a compensation claim, being injured at work and being absent because of that injury are all workplace rights under the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act (Part 3-1). Dismissal because of a workplace right is adverse action, and the Commission presumes the protected reason unless the employer proves otherwise — the burden sits squarely on you. Section 352 separately protects employees temporarily absent because of illness or injury: an injured worker’s absence is presumptively temporary until medical evidence says otherwise.

When Is Terminating an Injured Employee Lawful?

Lawful dismissals of an injured worker fall into four narrow pathways:

  1. Genuine redundancy — the position is genuinely no longer required for operational reasons unconnected to the injury. If the role could have been held open, the “redundancy” will be seen as a sham.
  2. Established incapacity — clear medical evidence that the employee cannot return to any suitable duties and their statutory entitlements are exhausted. A last resort.
  3. Serious misconduct unrelated to the injury — conduct that would justify summary dismissal in any circumstances.
  4. Documented performance or restructuring reasons — evidenced concerns independent of the injury, handled with procedural fairness.

Each pathway needs evidence dated before the decision — the Commission asks what your documents showed at the time. Our termination of employment resources cover the notice, final pay and documentation requirements for each ground.

The Legal Risks of Dismissing an Injured Employee

A general protections claim is uncapped — compensation is whatever the Commission considers appropriate, with no statutory ceiling. Even the perception that a claim influenced the decision is dangerous. An unfair dismissal claim can be lodged within 21 days of dismissal, with reinstatement first and compensation capped at the lesser of six months’ pay or $95,050 — half the $190,100 high income threshold applying from 1 July 2026. Add discrimination exposure under s 351 for treating a worker less favourably because of a disability, and one dismissal can attract three parallel causes of action. Planning an unfair dismissal defence before the decision is far cheaper than litigating it after — and if a claim lands, our guide to responding to an unfair dismissal claim steps through the response process.

⚠️ Injury-related dismissal carries uncapped risk

Dismissing an employee because of their injury or compensation claim is adverse action with no compensation cap. In NSW, dismissing within 52 weeks of injury solely or principally because of the injury is an offence. Get legal advice before terminating an injured worker.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways for Employers

  • ✓The injury itself can never be the lawful reason — only genuine redundancy, established incapacity or unrelated conduct can be.
  • ✓The Commission presumes adverse action when dismissal timing links to a compensation claim; the employer carries the burden of proof.
  • ✓Injured workers get the same NES notice, accrued leave and redundancy pay as anyone else.
  • ✓Check the state compensation scheme before acting — each state adds protected-period rules.
  • ✓Document the injury-independent reason before the dismissal, not after the claim arrives.

Fair Work Centre

Need help with unfair dismissal defence?

Our employment lawyers advise employers only — no call centres, no generalists. Get straight answers from people who know the Fair Work Act inside out.

Free Templates

Get free employment agreement templates — Basic, Full-Time, Part-Time & Casual.

Download Free Templates

How Does Firing an Employee Affect the Employer?

The commercial consequences are real. Workers compensation premiums are experience-rated, so a contested dismissal on top of an accepted claim can push your premium up at renewal, and a poorly handled termination can convert a partial-liability dispute into a full common law claim. Add the replacement hire and months defending even a weak claim — and in tight labour markets, a harsh reputation travels fast.

Do You Have to Give an Employee a Reason for Termination?

Strictly, the dismissal letter need not spell out the reason — but that is a technicality, not a strategy. The Commission will require you to state and prove a valid reason under s 385, and for an injured worker silence is worse: no documented, injury-independent reason is itself evidence that the injury was the reason. Best practice is written notice stating the genuine ground, the NES notice period and the final pay arrangements. The Fair Work Ombudsman’s notice and final pay rules set the minimums, and injured workers are entitled to the same notice, accrued annual leave and redundancy pay as anyone else.

Terminating an Injured Employee in NSW

Workers compensation is state-run, so protections depend on where the injury occurred. In NSW, the Workplace Injury Management and Compensation Act 1998 makes it an offence to dismiss a worker within 52 weeks of injury solely or principally because of the injury, with disputes handled by the Personal Injury Commission; Victoria and Queensland have equivalent scheme legislation. The practical rule everywhere: check the state scheme’s protections with your lawyer before acting, because the federal claim rides on top of whatever the state scheme adds.

The Safe Process: Steps Before You Dismiss an Injured Employee

Employer discussing a return to work plan before terminating an injured employee

  1. Get the medical picture in writing — current capacity certificates and specialist evidence before relying on incapacity.
  2. Test the return-to-work plan first — document genuine suitable duties offered and the response.
  3. Separate the reasons on paper — a decision file showing the operational, capacity or conduct reason independent of the injury, dated before the dismissal.
  4. Check the state scheme — protected periods (such as NSW’s 52 weeks) and insurer notification requirements.
  5. Give notice properly — full NES notice or pay in lieu, accrued leave paid out, reasons stated in writing.
  6. Get advice before you act — a one-hour review of the decision file is the cheapest insurance in employment law.

The right documents make the difference. Our free employment law document templates include termination checklists and warning letters, and our general protections claims guide sets out the adverse action framework in detail.

Frequently Asked Questions

Only if the injury plays no genuine part in the reason. Lawful grounds are a genuine redundancy, established incapacity after the compensation entitlement period is exhausted with clear medical evidence, or misconduct unrelated to the injury. Dismissal because of the injury or the claim is adverse action under the Fair Work Act 2009, and the employer carries the burden of proving the real reason before the Commission.

An injured worker’s employment can end lawfully, but the timing invites scrutiny. The Fair Work Commission presumes a dismissal linked to injury, absence or a compensation claim was motivated by it unless the employer proves otherwise, and state schemes add protected periods — NSW makes it an offence to dismiss within 52 weeks of injury solely or principally because of the injury. Document and legally review any such decision first.

An injury at work is not a shield against every dismissal, but making a workers compensation claim is a workplace right, so dismissing an employee because of the claim or injury is unlawful adverse action with uncapped compensation. The employer must point to a genuine, injury-independent reason — a true redundancy or documented misconduct — supported by evidence that existed at the time.

The employee receives written notice under the National Employment Standards (up to five weeks by service length, or pay in lieu), accrued annual leave and any redundancy entitlements, and a record of the stated reason. A former employee then has 21 days to lodge an unfair dismissal application with the Fair Work Commission. Keep the decision file and letters — the Commission assesses the reason from the documents, not later recollections.

Yes, but only for a genuine operational reason that would have applied had the employee never been injured. If the duties still exist and could have been performed on suitable duties, the Commission will treat the redundancy as a contrivance to remove the worker. Document the business case, the before-and-after structure and the consultation process.

Yes. Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 defines a workplace right to include making a claim or inquiry under a workplace law, which covers claiming compensation, reporting an injury and participating in return-to-work processes. Dismissing or prejudicing an employee because they exercised that right is adverse action, and the compensation is uncapped.

There is no statutory cap on general protections compensation — the Commission can order lost remuneration plus an amount for hurt and distress. By contrast, unfair dismissal compensation is capped at the lesser of six months’ pay or $95,050, half the $190,100 high income threshold applying from 1 July 2026. An injured-worker dismissal can trigger both claims plus a state dispute, so aggregate exposure routinely exceeds the cap.

The same as any other employee: NES notice of one to five weeks depending on service, or pay in lieu, plus accrued annual leave and, for a genuine redundancy, redundancy pay of up to 16 weeks for long-serving employees of larger employers. Being on compensation does not reduce these entitlements.

Join Fair Work Centre

Protect your business with the right HR support.

Join hundreds of Australian employers who rely on Fair Work Centre for employment law advice, HR documents, and Fair Work Commission representation.

Disclaimer: Fair Work Centre is an independent private organisation providing advisory services to employers only. It is not associated with or authorised by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any government authority. This article contains general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your circumstances, speak to one of our employment lawyers.
imgLeft

Get Your FREE Employer’s Quick Guide to Avoiding Termination Claims.

Protect your business from costly legal disputes with practical, step-by-step guidance.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

What’s your goal today?

1

If you’re an employer seeking guidance about an employee issue:

  • Workplace Advice: Not a member? Call us today on 1300 161 828 to see how we can help you and your business.
  • Client Membership Pricing: For unlimited employment law advice, HR documents/templates, and ongoing support, consider joining as a client member. Learn about becoming a client member here.
3

If you are a employer who wants to log in:

  • Already a member? Log in here to access all your resources, including templates and expert guidance.
2

If you are an employee:

4

Join our team.

  • We’re always looking for the best talent. If you’re an Employment Lawyer with 10+ years of experience and a passion for small business, start a conversation with us.
5

Contact us.

Free Initial Legal Guidance For Employers

Speak to an Employment Lawyer at Fair Work Centre

To change or request cancellation of your Client Membership, please email us with your request at: info@fairworkcentre.com.au.

Refer to our Terms of Service for changes or cancellation requests.

Request Call Back

Employers / HR Managers:  1300 161 828
Employees / Workers:  13 13 94

If you would like more information about any of our professional products or services, feel free to contact us, or simply fill in our enquiry form.

You must be logged in to submit this form